PBE News
PBE on the Web
Home
Article Index
Bookstore
Subscribe
Webinar
Sponsors
Agglomeration
Equipment

GEA Process Engineering
Hapman
Hosokawa Micron Powder Systems
K R Komarek

Airlocks, Blowers & Related Equipment
FLSmidth
GEA Process Engineering
K-Tron
Schenck Process
Smoot
Triple/S Dynamics
Vortex Valves

Bagging Equipment
Chantland
GEA Process Engineering
Hapman
Taylor Products

Bin Activators, Vibrators & Material Flow Aids
Acrison
FLSmidth
K-Tron
Metalfab Inc
Smoot
Solimar Pneumatics
Vac-U-Max

Bin Level Indicators
FLSmidth
K-Tron

Bulk Bag Fillers & Dischargers
Acrison
Chantland
Flexicon
GEA Process Engineering
Hapman
K-Tron
Machine and Process Design Inc
Metalfab Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Nol-Tec
Schenck Process
Taylor Products
Tecweigh
Vac-U-Max

Bulk Bags
Chantland
Taylor Products
Tecweigh

Custom Services
Acrison
Chantland
Flexicon
FLSmidth
Jenike & Johanson
K-Tron
MECO Seal div of Woodex Bearing Co
Metalfab Inc
Nol-Tec
Tecweigh
Vortex Valves

Dryers
GEA Process Engineering
Hosokawa Micron Powder Systems
K-Tron
Marion Mixers
MECO Seal div of Woodex Bearing Co

Dust Collector Media
Camfil APC
Donaldson Torit
Schenck Process
Smoot

Dust Collectors & Related Equipment
Acrison
Camfil APC
Donaldson Torit
FLSmidth
Nol-Tec
Schenck Process
Smoot
Vac-U-Max
Vortex Valves

Explosion Venting & Suppression
Schenck Process

Feeders
Acrison
Chantland
Hapman
Jenike & Johanson
K-Tron
Machine and Process Design Inc
MECO Seal div of Woodex Bearing Co
Metalfab Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Schenck Process
Smoot
Taylor Products
Tecweigh
Triple/S Dynamics
Vac-U-Max

Flow Meters
Acrison
K-Tron
Schenck Process

Linings (Abrasion Resistant)
FLSmidth
Vortex Valves

Material Handling
Acrison
Cablevey Conveyors
Chantland
Flexicon
FLSmidth
GEA Process Engineering
Hapman
Hosokawa Micron Powder Systems
Jenike & Johanson
K-Tron
Lorenz Conveying Products
Machine and Process Design Inc
Metalfab Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Nol-Tec
Schenck Process
Sentry Equipment
Smoot
Taylor Products
Tecweigh
Triple/S Dynamics
Vac-U-Max
Vortex Valves

Mechanical Conveyors
Acrison
Cablevey Conveyors
Chantland
Flexicon
GEA Process Engineering
Hapman
KWS Manufacturing Co Ltd
Machine and Process Design Inc
MECO Seal div of Woodex Bearing Co
Metalfab Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Taylor Products
Tecweigh
Triple/S Dynamics
Vac-U-Max

Metal Detectors & Separators
Industrial Magnetics

Mixers & Blenders
Acrison
FLSmidth
GEA Process Engineering
Hapman
Hosokawa Micron Powder Systems
K-Tron
Machine and Process Design Inc
Marion Mixers
MECO Seal div of Woodex Bearing Co
Metalfab Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Nol-Tec

Particle Analyzers
Hosokawa Micron Powder Systems

Pneumatic Conveying Equipment
Flexicon
FLSmidth
GEA Process Engineering
Hapman
Industrial Magnetics
K-Tron
Lorenz Conveying Products
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Nol-Tec
Schenck Process
Smoot
Vac-U-Max
Vortex Valves

Product Reclaim Equipment
FLSmidth
GEA Process Engineering
Machine and Process Design Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Vac-U-Max

Samplers
FLSmidth
Sentry Equipment
Tecweigh

Sifters, Screeners & Classifiers
Hosokawa Micron Powder Systems
K-Tron
Machine and Process Design Inc
Triple/S Dynamics

Size Reduction Equipment
GEA Process Engineering
Hapman
Hosokawa Micron Powder Systems
Jet Pulverizer Co
Machine and Process Design Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Triple/S Dynamics

Sizing Tools
FLSmidth

Storage
Acrison
FLSmidth
Hapman
Jenike & Johanson
Machine and Process Design Inc
Metalfab Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc

Vacuum Cleaning Equipment
Camfil APC
Vac-U-Max

Valves
FLSmidth
GEA Process Engineering
K-Tron
Lorenz Conveying Products
Schenck Process
Smoot
Vortex Valves

Weighing Equipment
Acrison
Chantland
Flexicon
Hapman
K-Tron
Metalfab Inc
National Bulk Equipment Inc
Schenck Process
Smoot
Taylor Products
Tecweigh
Vac-U-Max

Other
Acrison
Chantland
Flexicon
FLSmidth
Jenike & Johanson
K-Tron
Marion Mixers
MECO Seal div of Woodex Bearing Co
Tecweigh
Vortex Valves


Bulk-Online
 
» Skip to Answer
More Questions and Answers
Q: When designing a pneumatic conveying system, is there a reason to prefer vacuum conveying over pressure conveying when using a bulk bag (FIBC) as the material source?
A: Gary Saunders, Smoot, a div. of Magnum Systems, says:
Yes. Typically, pneumatic conveying systems transferring from a bulk bag unloader are designed as vacuum systems, if there are no extenuating circumstances.
Pressure systems require an airlock at the pickup point. In most pneumatic conveying systems, this airlock comes in the form of a rotary valve. Rotary valves, however, leak air in pressure service. The leakage, better known as blow-by air, can interfere with a bulk bag's discharge if it has no other place to go, by turning the bag into a balloon. This can be worked around by adding a second valve and intermediate vent, but this adds height and cost.
Vacuum systems, in contrast, require their airlock at the system discharge, not the pickup point. Since the pickup point is at or near ambient pressure, typically no leakage occurs. This allows the bag to discharge more freely and at a more ergonomic height for the operator.
As you can see, while not an impossibility, design complications, costs, or height issues can quickly ensue. If you're at all unsure what design may be optimal for your application, contact an experienced design engineer.
Smoot, a div. of Magnum Systems, is a process company specializing in pneumatic conveying, packaging, and automation.
To send us your questions email kcarrigan@cscpub.com
back to top ↑
Copyright 2013, CSC Publishing Inc. All rights reserved.
PBE-News provides information updates about the dry bulk materials processing and handling industry twice a month. The opt-out link below will allow you to opt out of future PBE-News. This will in no way affect our contact methods regarding your subscription or communication. Thank you.
 
PBE-News Editor
Kayla Carrigan
kcarrigan@cscpub.com
 
PBE-News Editor
Christine Bernier Lienke
clienke@cscpub.com
 
PBE-News Designer
Kurt Beckman
kbeckman@cscpub.com